Amos Yee

Why Sex with Babies is Bad

Obvious opinion to have I know. But that’s unfortunately still a debate among the pro-contact portion of the Pedophile Rights’ community. I’m very sorry I made comments endorsing baby sex in my older videos, it’s time to amend my position.

There have definitely been accounts of children as young as 4 years old, having consensual sexual acts with adults, some of these children even initiated and seduced the adult. In those cases, of course those acts should be legal and the adult shouldn’t be considered a ‘child molester’. The adult was seduced by the kid who wanted it. It’s probably true that most children below the age of 8 do not have the cognitive ability to be able to consent to sex. But obviously, different children mature at different rates. There have been clear exceptions, and so the few instances of 5-year-olds voluntarily engaging in sexual acts with an adult, should not be legally penalised.

However, it seems like the line is drawn at age 3. There have not been a single reported instance of consensual sexual acts between someone age 3 and below. At that young an age, it’s impossible to consent to sex. It’s impossible for them to have a basic understanding of the act and to make a decision, and all sexual acts with children at that age have been exploitative. Just because a baby can walk to the fire truck instead of the Hello Kitty, does not of course mean he understands sex and has the capacity to make a decision.

So if people wanted to just reduce the age of consent to 3, I’d be fine with that. I would simply just abolish age of consent laws altogether. That doesn’t mean I endorse sex with children of all ages. Molest and rape laws will obviously still exist, and will automatically account for all acts with children below age 3. Abolishing age of consent laws completely will just ensure that the sexual acts that are consensual at any age, will not be penalised.

So yes, baby sex is bad. Pedophiles, stop trying to defend sex with babies because that’s indefensible and opponents can easily discredit and embarrass you if you hold that position. Defending all other sexual acts with children however, especially children at the age of 10 to 16 where there are definite peer-reviewed scientific studies showing most of the acts have been consensual, and that adults being sexual with children have had less risk of harm than typical sexual relationships between 2 adults. You can’t help but win with that.


Read Why we Should Defend Pedophiles here